|

 |
Other Issues |
 |
|
VOLUME 9 NO.2 JUNE-AUGUST 2008
|
 |
PATIENT-DOCTOR RELATIONSHIP
LIKE A PRAYER
|
|
|
Rafael Campo
|
Recalling his time as an exhausted
intern working through a last, long,
in-patient rotation among homeless
men with AIDS, physician, poet, and
essayist Rafael Campo tells of a
harrowing experience on the ward.
That experience allows him to
realize his capacity for great
empathy toward the least among us,
while also providing readers with a
meditation on the origins of
altruism under the most trying of
circumstances. |
As I went about inattentively jotting down
his vital signs, and then taking a
perfunctory listen to his heart, he
entreated me with a voice so raspy from
disuse it was almost gentle: “Hey, doc, when
you get to church this morning, pray for
me.” A few soundless moments passed. After I
had said nothing in response, he added with
the same hoarseness that at higher volume
became a surprisingly vicious snarl, “Yeah,
you must be a real good f…… Catholic, with a
name like that.” Now I was annoyed, to have
been startled out of my dim reverie, and by
such a crass slur. Was he referring to the
Latino-voweled surname blazoned on my
plastic ID tag, I wondered – or perhaps, I
thought with rising contempt, he was
familiar with the lesser-known archangel
Rafael?
I had simply been trying to get through my tedious daily
morning work rounds without a hitch, the
hypnotic lines of Madonna’s latest hit song,
which I had blasted on my car stereo on the
way to the county hospital, still pulsing
suggestively over and over again in my head:
“Just like a prayer/your voice can take me
there/just like a muse to me /you are a
mystery. . .” For the whole of the
twenty-minute drive in to work that day, I
had kept my car’s front windows rolled all
the way down to let the bracing wind and all
of frivolously sundrenched San Francisco
pour unimpeded into me as I sped down
Potrero. But the deepening poverty was too
obvious to ignore, the Mission district
looking more and more like a destitute Latin
American country with each passing block.
I had not even realized that the gorgeous day I wanted so
desperately to relish was a Sunday. For me,
a dysfunctional intern stumbling through my
last in-patient rotation with only randomly
and infrequently scheduled days off, each
day had grown monotonously more and more
indistinguishable from the one before it.
Death was inevitable and omnipresent;
resurrection was not only impossible but
ludicrous. The hushed and somber hospital,
whose hermetically sealed neighborhoods of
illness and contagion went in house staff
parlance by various quasi-celestial
nicknames – the busy cancer unit was
sarcastically referred to as the Death Star,
and the grim and even more crowded AIDS ward
was known as the Temple of Doom – had long
been my exclusive place of dark worship and
forced atonement. If I would have preferred
to be in church, it was only because I so
despised the hospital.
His nurse entered with a gelatinously floppy bag of IV fluid
to hang. According to her, my patient had
been babbling incoherently off and on for
much of the night, yet I felt how
unmistakably and clearly these last few
words of his pierced me. Pray for him? This
patient was a filthy junkie who had bitten
another nurse in a squabble over his regular
methadone dose; numerous times, I had been
paged in the middle of the night and
awakened from a precious hour or two of
sleep to respond to his incessant demands
for other narcotic drugs to treat his
“pain,” always to arrive to find him resting
in apparent comfort amid half-emptied
take-out cartons of Chinese food brought in
by his rowdy, ponytailed friends. If I could
have hoped or prayed for anything, it would
have been that he’d be stone-cold dead when
I next returned to the ward.
Instead, to my chagrin, each morning he was still there, very
much alive and moaning and urinating in his
bed, or hurling the occasional intelligible
and angry epithet at me. Though nothing was
likely to salvage him at this point in his
illness, with his terminally low T-cell
count of 2, a long history of violence and
intravenous drug use, and widespread
aggressive lymphoma involving his central
nervous system, I was still leery of trying
anything new at all – even a begrudged
prayer – that might prolong his misery, and
thus my own. He was little more than a
disgusting chore to me, something akin to
mopping up a stubbornly grimy floor. In my
view, each new hospitalization he had
required, thickening his chart as if only to
make it heavier for me to lug back and forth
from medical records, was a waste of already
scarce public health dollars. This latest
crude remark of his was the last straw. I
stormed out of his room without even
bothering to finish examining him.
By simply going elsewhere in the hospital, however, I could not
escape him. I saw versions of him shadily
averting their eyes in the elevator,
hungrily consuming free food provided by the
methadone clinic in the cafeteria, and
wildly quarreling in the outdoors smoking
area off one of the hospital’s main
hallways. Wherever I looked, his blunt plea
would flood back to me, only to elicit the
same reflexive rage. Though one of my
intern’s strategies for conserving energy
was to minimize thinking whenever possible,
I found myself obsessively wondering whether
I walked around stooped by the heavy burden
of some unresolved religious guilt, so that
even my most ostensibly faithless and
disoriented patients could tell that I was
once a Catholic. My hip Ray-Ban sunglasses,
my pumping Madonna CDs, my chilling
surliness, even my Gay Pride T-shirts worn
secretly underneath my scrubs all failed to
secularize me sufficiently in the discerning
eyes of others. Even through the thick fog
of his delirium, somehow he had alighted
upon my name.
My name. I locked myself in a windowless staff
bathroom, the only place I could think of
where I could be completely alone, if the
pungent presence of ammonia were ignored. I
wondered: What secrets did a name betray? I
regarded it from a distance as if for the
first time, quietly pronouncing it over and
over to myself; undeniably, “Rafael Campo”
was as generically Latino as a colorful
street festival for a local miracle-working
Virgin, but my actual relationship to the
Catholic Church was much cooler than my
stereotypically churchgoing family’s. I was
a hard-core outcast for my supposedly sinful
life, and no longer even considered myself a
member of any faith. It amazed me that a
low-life like this patient, who probably had
stolen stereos from cars in the hospital
staffs parking lot to pay for the heroin he
was known to shoot directly into his IVs,
could still consider himself among God’s
children, worthy of a saving prayer. . . .
When that despicable AIDS patient finally did die, seizing
intractably and without my prayers, I was
glad, and relished his death over an
unappetizing late-night meal with a few of
my colleagues in the nearly deserted
cafeteria. Still, I knew he would only be
succeeded by others.
Sure enough, late one night on call a few days later, I
was paged to place an IV in yet another
patient with AIDS, one who belonged to an
intern for whom I was cross-covering. He was
an emaciated young man who had been
receiving wide-open fluid resuscitation for
dehydration, until he pulled out his first
catheter. His veins stood out beneath his
yellow skin so clearly that they seemed to
beckon me to enter them, so plump that my
mouth even watered a little. I prided myself
on my ability to obtain intravenous access,
so at first I was only mildly annoyed that
the nurse had called me to perform what
appeared to be so easy a stick. She was
probably overworked herself, though when I
had arrived an hour or two after her page
she seemed to be on a break, and this was
one task that could be unquestioningly
relegated to a defenseless intern, with the
automatic, well-rehearsed apology: “I’ve
tried three times, and I just can’t get it.”
In a few moments, I had gathered together the necessary
supplies in a small heap at the side of his
bed: a drape, some sterile gauze, a small
syringe filled with saline, a bottle of
iodine, a liter bag of normal saline and
some clear coiled tubing, a few strips of
tape, a rubber tourniquet, the flimsy but
requisite pair of latex gloves, and a
16-gauge Angiocath. I had selected such a
big needle partly to underscore to his
coffee-sipping nurse, without having to say
a word, how effortless the job would be for
someone competent. The patient remained
asleep while I set everything up, the arm I
had selected dangling lifelessly off the
side of the bed. When I tried to awaken him
to explain what I was doing, before I said
more than a few words he mumbled, “Just get
it over with and get the hell out of my
room.” Unfazed, I accepted his gruff
statement as informed consent and decided by
way of retribution not to bother with
lidocaine to numb the area. I positioned the
gleaming needle at the bifurcation of an
especially large vein, which was swollen
nicely under the pressure of the tourniquet
I had tightened while he still dozed.
As I applied traction with my other gloved hand above the
puncture site, I watched intently as the
needle pierced the skin delectably,
anticipating with confidence the bright
flash of red blood in the needle’s small
reservoir that would indicate that the lumen
of the catheter was inside the vein. I
marveled at the permission I had to inflict
pain, to assault another person with a sharp
object under the pretense that I was
actually helping him, but knowing that he
would be dead soon, just like the rest. I
was more surprised than annoyed when no
flash occurred, I was perfectly positioned,
and the vein was huge. I withdrew and made a
second attempt, again with no success. Sweat
began to trickle down my brow, and I had to
hold his arm down forcefully with the same
hand I was using to apply traction to the
vein; he was moaning more and more loudly
now. A purple hematoma was growing slowly
under his skin where I must have nicked the
vein, further unpleasant evidence that this
was a sentient, living being I was working
on, not just the cadaver I foresaw he would
become. On the third pass, with my hands
visibly trembling, I finally nailed it and,
feeling more than a bit relieved, looked
away for a moment. I needed to find the
syringe I would use to withdraw blood and
then flush in a small amount of saline to
confirm the patency of my line.
Perhaps it was the strange violation, the unwanted
communication of the outside world with so
intimate an interior space that aroused him;
perhaps it was the pain I knew I caused, but
which I so callously, even sadistically,
ignored as I focused on my task, that
prompted him to react. Before I knew what
had happened, he was sitting bolt upright,
screaming at the top of his lungs and
flailing his arms out in front of him,
scattering my neat pile of materials across
the floor. I tried to stop him. When the
same needle pierced my own skin, my first
thought was to deny the literal connection
between us, one that emotionally I had been
for so long incapable of accepting but that
was suddenly as lasting as metal, as pointed
as agony. Blood poured out of the hole in
his skin so profusely that in seconds the
left leg of my scrubs was soaked in it, and
I felt the cool slickness against my thigh,
perplexed that it did not feel warmer as it
was absorbed. I finally came enough to my
senses to call out for help and staggered to
the door of his room, leaving sticky, bloody
sneaker prints behind me, my path in life
momentarily made visible by another’s
suffering.
The look of horror on the nurse’s face pulled me across the
remaining dimensions through which I had
begun to drift, back into the real world.
After we had together restrained him enough
to apply pressure to the vein and control
the bleeding, I went directly to the sink.
Both gloves I wore were covered with quickly
drying blood, and when I peeled them off, I
noticed stonily that the one on my left hand
had been pierced through. I washed my hands
before looking at them and felt the sting of
the antiseptic soap in the middle of the
palm of my left hand, the same sinister hand
I had used to hold down his arm, the awful
hand that had felt the strain of his
weakened muscles against me and then the
needle’s terrible bite. Still afraid to
inspect the sore spot, I took my time
patting my hands dry and unwillingly noticed
flecks of blood on the crumpled white paper
as I tossed the used towels in the trash. So
I knew. My left hand balled in a fist, I
calmly announced to the nurse that I was
fine and that I needed to get changed into
some clean scrubs, before I exited the room
on wobbly legs; she seemed to hover above
the dark pool of blood, plump and white and
dumb as a dove, and the fact that she said
nothing to me made me wonder if she
suspected the truth.
The rent in my skin was only two or three millimeters
in size, though the small amount of blood
that had fanned out in the subcutaneous
tissue made a dusky red spot that was
alarmingly much bigger, maybe a centimeter
or so. I squeezed out whatever blood I
could, not knowing whether the drop or two I
was able to express was mine or his, or mine
mixed with his. I changed my scrub pants in
one of the deserted hallways of the
labyrinthine OR, the dried blood that had
soaked in pulling at the hair on my thigh as
I shucked them off, not caring if a stray
orderly or scrub nurse happened to spy me
undressed: I finally knew how human I was, I
was made acutely aware in one terrible
moment that all any of us has in the world
is the same body. I wanted to pray that I
had not been infected. I wanted to believe
that a god, any god, had protected me. After
I was changed, I found an open utility
closet and shut myself in it with the
syringes and plastic emesis basins and face
masks and blue gauzy hairnets close around
me. I stared into the wound in my palm
beneath the dim yellow light from a bare
bulb, my forsaken faith even more dim; I
found that I kept thinking of Christ, with
the incongruous and gruesome fact dancing in
my mind that in Roman crucifixions the nails
were driven not through the palms, as seen
in conventional depictions of Christ on the
cross, but through the wrists.
I recalled that I had once stuck myself with a needle a few
years before, as an inexperienced medical
student attempting to draw blood from
another patient with AIDS, but that incident
had left no mark in my skin, and I had found
no hole in the gloves I was wearing. Still,
I had been unable to sleep for weeks, and it
was several more months before I could even
talk about it with anyone. In contrast, what
was happening to me in the utility closet
felt like an opening, a revelation, a chance
for survival; though I certainly would not
report to the Needlestick Hotline what had
happened to me, perhaps there would be
someone else, some higher authority, who
would listen to me. Perhaps in the mixing of
my blood with another person’s, I could
learn the true meaning of forgiveness, I
could understand human failings, I could
begin to fathom how we all share original
sin. Perhaps in the possibility of dying of
AIDS myself, I could realize finally and
fully my capacity for empathy. Perhaps in a
prayer, in a poem, in an embrace and a kiss,
I could speak again to God.
These days, my version of the physician’s “God complex” is to
pray secretly at the bedsides of my
patients, sometimes thinking myself silly
for doing it, but finding it impossible not
to do so. Whatever my religion might be –
Catholic or Doctor Not of Theology, Queer
Sister of Perpetual Indulgence or Undecided
– I understand now that one’s faith is
intensely personal, in the same way each
individual has his own hopes and dreams, and
that it can be shared not only within the
thick walls of churches but also in the open
wards of a hospital. In my visions now, the
patients who are dying, or who are getting
well, all have a place to go; each holds
inside and is held by the beating heart and
the feverish closeness of his loved ones.
Even the most despised and isolated of
patients has someone to whom he can turn,
one who truly does have the power to heal, a
hope that is the source of all poems. The
terrifying needle stick is just a reminder,
the bearded chaplain on his rounds exudes a
kind of comfort, the hideous skin lesion
becomes the glorious impact of God’s touch.
Today I see that the nurse carrying away
feces in a bedpan is an angel; the quiet
glance we exchange is the meaning of life.¨
Source: Rafael Campo. Like A Prayer. In: R.
Coles, MD; R. Testa, eds. A life in
Medicine: A Literary Anthology. New York:
The New York Press, 2002:12-18.
|
THE WISDOM OF LAO TZU
Health is the greatest possession.
Contentment is the greatest
treasure. Confidence is the greatest
friend. Non-being is the greatest
joy.
He who is contented is rich.
He who controls others may be
powerful, but he who has mastered
himself is mightier still.
Great acts are made up of small
deeds.
Give a man a fish and you feed him
for a day. Teach him how to fish and
you feed him for a lifetime.
An ant on the move does more than a
dozing ox.
In dwelling, live close to the
ground. In thinking, keep to the
simple. In conflict, be fair and
generous. In governing, don't try to
control. In work, do what you enjoy.
In family life, be completely
present.
Kindness in words creates
confidence. Kindness in thinking
creates profoundness. Kindness in
giving creates love.
Music in the soul can be heard by
the universe.
The journey of a thousand miles
begins with one step.
The Chinese name Lao Tsu means Old
Master. Lao Tzu lived twenty-five
centuries ago in ancient China.
Legend has it that King Wu of Zhou
appointed him head librarian of the
royal archives at Luoyang. In this
capacity Lao Tzu was able to immerse
himself in the study of history,
philosophy and literature, gaining
wisdom and insights along the way.
According to legend, Confucius
visited with Lao Tzu and came away
in awe of Lao Tzu's intellect.
Confucius recognized in Lao Tzu a
deep understanding about the world
that was above his own, and went so
far as to liken Lao Tzu to the
mysterious dragon.
Lao Tzu wrote a small book in two
parts, expressing his accumulated
learnings in brief, concise yet
profound language. This book
survived over 2,500 years and came
to be known as the Tao Te Ching (The
Way).
|

|
|